Showing posts with label TN Politicians. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TN Politicians. Show all posts

Saturday, June 12, 2010

Much ado about McAdoo

Most Americans today will not recognize the name William Gibbs McAdoo Jr. But his career made him very popular during his life. Born in 1863 in Georgia, his family moved to Knoxville when he was 14 years old where his father took a job as a professor at East Tennessee University, the forerunner of the University of Tennessee.

In 1882 William graduated from the school his father worked at. In 1885 he moved to Chattanooga where he practiced Law and then in 1892 to New York where he led the project to complete the first rail tunnels under the Hudson river. His success made him popular in New York, and the tunnels are still in use today. Sadly though, his wife passed away in 1912.

Later that year he was made the vice chairman of the Democratic National Congress, and worked on Woodrow Wilson's campaign and was rewarded with the post of Secretary of the Treasury. Eventually he  married Woodrow Wilson's daughter, Eleanor.

At the onset of the first World War, European countries planned on selling their US assets, converting them into gold and taking the gold back to Europe. This would have depleted the US Gold reserve sending the economy into recession. To prevent this William closed the stock exchange for four months. This forced the European nations to buy American goods using IOUs against their assets in America, allowing the gold to stay put. With a single act he set in motion events that led to placing the US at the top of the world economic stage for at least the next century.

His later career was not as spectacular. He made two failed attempts to secure the Democratic nomination for President of the US, in 1920 and 1924. In the 1924 election he received an endorsement from the KKK, which he did not denounce. He also narrowly escaped being dragged into the Teapot Dome Scandal. He did get elected Senator from California in 1933, but he only served one term, during which Eleanor divorced him. Soon it became evident why. Two months after the divorce was final and at the age of 71 he married his 26-year-old private nurse.

So what is McAdoo's connection to Tennessee Mormonism? Well, in the spring of 1881, while a student at the University of Tennessee in Knoxville, William and his cousin Charles F. Humes, were both on the debating team for the Chi Delta Society. The topic that day was "Resolved, That Mormonism in the United States Should be Abolished." And William and Charles were assigned to defend Mormonism! They wrote to an unnamed Utah "Congressman" (probably Utah delegate George Q. Cannon) asking for help, which they apparently received.

On the evening of the debate the sentiment of the crowd was against them. McAdoo recalled that "the nice respectable people of Knoxville came to the conclusion that there must be something wrong with us, or we would not argue in favor of plural wives." But using quotes from the Book of Mormon, the US Constitution, and arguments provided by the congressman, the two made quite an impression on those present. "The judges retired for consultation and when they returned they announced that Humes and I had won the debate." I have no evidence how this experience colored his opinion of the LDS Church during his political career.

[Charles F. Humes does not follow his cousin's illustrious career, but did make a name for himself at the center of quarrel between the faculty and the board of the University of Tennessee.]

Sunday, February 14, 2010

Congressman Emerson Etheridge of Tennessee

Emerson Etheridge was born in North Carolina in 1819. He moved to Tennessee in 1831 with his parents an became a lawyer in Dresden, Tennessee. He began his political career in 1845 when he was elected a member of the Tennessee House of Representatives.
He was in and out of the U S House of Representatives. He was a member of the Whig Party, the American Party and the Opposition Party. He was famously pro-slavery. But his connection to Mormonism was his April 2nd, 1860 speech against Polygamy. I have not been able to find online but since it fills 16 manuscript pages, I probably wouldn't include it here anyway.

At question was whether congress should have the authority to legislate against polygamy in the territories. In 1856, the Republican Party added to its platform a plank to end the "twin-relics of barbarism, polygamy and slavery." Prior to this, marriage laws belonged to the States. But anti-polygamy legislation gained wide support from both the north and south in an era when the two agreed on very little.

Emerson is a good example of the conflicted nature of southern politics. While he hated polygamy, he acknowledged that the very same arguments that supported the eradication of polygamy by federal authority could be used against slavery. In the end he voted for the anti polygamy legislation anyway.

He ended his career in Congress with the start of the Civil War. After the war he was active in Tennessee local politics including a run for governor. He died in Dresden, Tennessee in 1902.

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Thomas A. Kercheval: dedicated anti-polygamist

Thomas was born in Maury County Tennessee on January 16th 1837 to Thomas Kercheval and Mary M Kennedy. He went to Virginia for Law school at Emory and Henry College. He passed the bar in Tennessee 1860 and practiced law in Fayetteville, Lincoln County. After a couple of years he began a political career as the U. S. Provst Marshal from 1862-1864, which required him to move to Nashville. That position alone demonstrates he must have been loyal to the Union. He was a member of the Unionist Party and the Republican Party.

Somehow he was appointed by the reconstruction government to the Tennessee General Assembly from Lincoln County in 1865 until 1867. His appointment cause quite a stir since he no longer lived in Lincoln County. Afterwards he practiced law in Nashville until his election back to the General Assembly from 1869-1871, this time representing the Davidson County (Nashville).

He served in the City Council fron 1871 to 1872, and then as Mayor of Nashville from 1872-1873. In 1874 he married Alice G Brien, the daughter of a Nashville judge. He then returned to as Mayor of Nashville in 1875 until 1883.

In 1885 he was elected to the General Assembly again where he served until 1887. It was during this third stint in the General Assembly that he authored a bill which prohibited the teaching of polygamy in the State of Tennessee. As far as I can tell, it was enforced only once.

He went back to city government, serving as Mayor from 1886 to 1887 (yes, I saw the overlap.) and then as a member of the Board of Public Works from 1888 to 1893. Afte his public service was over he continued practicing law in Nashvile until "infirmaties of age" required him to retire. Thomas died on March 22, 1915 and is buried in Mount Olivet Cemetery in Nashville.

Sunday, March 15, 2009

Hugh Kirk Plummer

This is another in a series on alleged vigilantes at the Cane Creek Massacre]

Having gone through the list of known vigilantes, I get to the first person for which the evidence of his participation is less reliable. From here on I run the danger of accusing someone of participating that had no real involvement. And yet to have been involved would not have held the same stigma in 1884 that it does today. Often these were "prominent men." And if there were any of the alleged vigilantes who were considered a pillar of the community it was Dr. Hugh Kirk Plummer. He was well respected, well educated, and well known. As a doctor, he frequently travelled around Lewis, Hickman and Perry counties to tend to the sick. If he were typical, he was paid very little for his services.

He was born in the Palestine community, Lewis County, January 20 1844.

During the Civil War, Hugh enlisted in the Confederate Army as a private in Company H, 19th (Biffle’s) Brigade, Tennessee Cavalry. His name is on the roll of Company E, same regiment, at the surrender of command by General Richard Taylor of Citronella, AL, May 10,1865.

Hugh married Mary Narcissus in Palestine, Lewis County, TN on Sept 25, 1866. He received his M.D. in 1867 from the University of Tennessee when it was still in Nashville. He practiced medicine in Lewis, Hickman, and Perry counties and before the birth of his last daughter moved his family to Linden TN.

The family attended the Methodist Church and Hugh was a member of several Masonic Lodges. He was also a member of the State Legislature from 1881 to 1883, representing Lewis, Hickman and Perry counties. He died in Linden TN on August 15, 1898. (Lewis County est 1843)

Several sources name him as being in the mob that came to the Condor home on August 10th, 1884.

Hyrun Belnap recorded in his autobiography the contents of a letter from John Garrett. The letter listed 12 names as being men in the mob. Dr Plummer is on the list, though in 1914, when the letter was written Dr Plummer was already dead.

Willard Washington Bean, recorded an interview in 1895 with John Anthony who had lived on Cane Creek near the Condor farm.


"The Condor boys decided to defend the Mormons and one of them grabbed a gun from over the door, but before he got a chance to use it, Doc Plummer, who seemed to be one of the leaders; shot him down."
John Anthony's testimony should be viewed with skepticism. He also claimed that the mob showed up in "white cap uniform." Of course, this was incorrect. The mob at Cane Creek wore colorful outlandish costumes, not the "white" that has become the well know image it is today. This error makes me seriously doubt John Anthony had first hand knowledge of the massacre, though not necessarily doubt his claim that "Doc Plummer" participated.

Another person Bean interviewed, identified only as Bill and who admitted he was not living in Lewis County when the massacre occurred, related the following:
"One of the Condor boys asked them what they meant by comin here with guns and reached for his rifle over the door, and while one of the mobbers wus grapplin with him for the gun, Doc Plummer shot the boy down. This was the match that touched off the powder."
It is hard to believe Bill's account since it was at best second hand, and quite possibly more distant than that. But we can certainly say he heard about Doctor Plummer's alleged participation and that it was considered common knowledge.

Miles L. Jones reported in 1934 that based on interviews with Ruben Mathis and Andrew Jackson Talley the following about the doctor.

"Someone was asked to go for a doctor, which they did, as he lived just a few miles from there; when they arrived at his house he had just unsaddled his horse that showed signs of having been recently ridden, and the doctor had not yet removed all of his disguise, and it was plainly evident that he was one of the mob. He responded, however, and pretended to give proper assistance to Sister Conder. He set her limb, but it afterwards developed that the leg was not properly set, and the bones were lapped an inch or so, and consequently she was crippled the rest of her life; she did, however, get able to walk around, and lived for nearly 32 years after the occurrence."
Dr. Plummer's name is never used in this version, but it is not unreasonable to assume about whom this story referred. There were a small number of physicians in rural Lewis County. And fewer who lived near the Condor home.

Using Jeremy Ricketts characterization of the typical vigilante, Dr Plummer fits the profile. He was a prominent member of the community who feels an obligation to the safety of the community. Of the all the members of the mob, he is the most likely to be motivated purely by the perceived danger presented by the Mormons missionaries rumored salacious intentions. The only surprise is that he easily believed the scurrilous stories for which there was no evidence.